## Tractate Soferim Chapter 20

###### Tractate Soferim 20:1
[Tractate Soferim 20:1](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:1)

ואין מברכין על הירח אלא במוצאי שבת כשהוא מבושם ובכלים נאים ותולה עיניו כנגדה ומיישר את רגליו ומברך אשר במאמרו ברא שחקים וברוח פיו כל צבאם חוק וזמן נתן להם שלא ישנו את תפקידם פועלי אמת שפעולתו אמת וללבנה אמר שתתחדש באור יקר ועטרת תפארת לעמוסי בטן שהם עתידים להתחדש כמותה לפאר יוצרם על כבוד מלכותו בא"י מקדש ראשי חדשים:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
The benediction over the moon must not be said except at the conclusion of the Sabbath when one is in an exhilarated mood¹ and well dressed. [43*a*] He directs his eyes towards the moon, places his feet together and pronounces the benediction ‘Who² didst create the heavens by Thy word and all their hosts by the breath of Thy mouth. Thou didst set for them a fixed law and time that they should not change their ordained task. They are glad and rejoice to perform the will of their Possessor.³ They act loyally, for their⁴ action is truth. To the moon Thou didst say that it should renew itself with a precious light and a diadem of beauty for those who have been sustained from the womb⁵ who, like it, will be renewed in the future and glorify their Creator for the majesty of His kingdom. Blessed art Thou, O Lord, Who hallowest the New Moons’.⁶

footnotes:
¹ After the happiness of the Sabbath day.
² Preceded, as all benedictions, by ‘Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God, King of the universe’.
³ Inserted by GRA and M; omitted by V. H adds it in the textual notes.
⁴ So GRA, M and H. V has ‘for his’.
⁵ A reference to Israel (cf. Is. 46, 3).
⁶ H reads ‘hallowest Israel and the New Moons’; the reading of GRA is ‘Who renewest the months’.


###### Tractate Soferim 20:2
[Tractate Soferim 20:2](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:2)

ואומר ג"פ סימן טוב סימן טוב [תהיה] לכל ישראל ברוך יוצרך ברוך עושך ברוך קונך ברוך בוראך ורוקד ג׳ רקידות כנגדה ואומר ג"פ כשם שאני רוקד כנגדך ואיני נוגע ביך כך אם ירקדו אחרים כנגדי [להזיקני] לא יגעו בי תפול עליהם אימתה ופחד ולמפרע אמן אמן סלה הללויה ואומר לחבירו ג"פ שלום וילך לביתו בלב טוב והדא היא לכל מפסיקין לראשי חדשים:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
Then one says three times, ‘An auspicious omen, an auspicious omen, shall it be for all Israel. Blessed be He Who formed thee, blessed be Thy Maker, blessed be thy Possessor, blessed be thy Creator’. Turning in the direction of the moon,⁷ he jumps three times and exclaims three times, ‘As I jump towards thee but do not⁸ touch thee, so if others should jump against me to hurt me may they not touch me. Let terror and dread fall upon them and may this be retrospective, Amen, Amen, Selah. Praise ye the Lord’. He then says ‘Peace’ three times to his fellow and goes home with a cheerful heart. That is [the conclusion of the regulations] concerning the interruptions for New Moons.⁹

footnotes:
⁷ lit. ‘towards it’.
⁸ M reads ‘and cannot’ which is the reading in the ritual.
⁹ Cf. XVII, 2f where the regulations for the New Moon began and, with many interruptions, insertions and amplifications, continued to the end of this Rule.


###### Tractate Soferim 20:3
[Tractate Soferim 20:3](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:3)

כיצד מפסיקין לחנוכה אמרו בעשרים וחמשה בכסליו מדליקין נר חנוכה ואסור להדליק בנר ישן ואם אין לו אלא ישן מלבנו באור יפה יפה ואין מגביהין אותו ממקומו עד שיכבה:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
What are the regulations respecting *Ḥanukkah?*¹⁰’, a reference to XVII, 2 where *Ḥanukkah* was first introduced in this set of regulations with the statement, ‘The sequence … is interrupted for … *Ḥanukkah’*. The Rabbis said: On the twenty-fifth day of *Kislew*¹¹ the *Ḥanukkah* lamp is kindled,¹² and it is forbidden to use an old lamp;¹³ but if a person has only an old lamp, he must thoroughly heat it in fire;¹⁴ nor may [the *Ḥanukkah* lamp] be moved¹⁵ from its place before it is extinguished.¹⁶ light, commemorating the miracles which led up to the celebration (cf. Rule 5), is sacred, is only to be looked at and must not be used for any other purpose.

footnotes:
¹⁰ lit. ‘how do we interrupt for Ḥanukkah
¹¹ The ninth Heb. month on the twenty-fifth of which the Festival begins.
¹² This takes place on the preceding evening, the night belonging to the following day.
¹³ If it is an earthen lamp, because the burnt oil renders it unsightly.
¹⁴ To burn away the old oil, after which the lamp may be used.
¹⁵ lit. ‘lifted’.
¹⁶ Carrying the lamp about while it is burning might cause suspicion that one is making a profane use of it; but the Ḥanukkah


###### Tractate Soferim 20:4
[Tractate Soferim 20:4](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:4)

מצות הדלקתו משקיעת החמה עד שיכלה הרגל מן השוק ואע"פ שאין ראייה לדבר זכר לדבר (שמות י״ג:כ״ב) לא ימיש עמוד הענן יומם ואם הדליקו ביום אין נאותין ממנו ואי׳ מברכין עליו שכך אמרו אין מברכין על הנר עד שיאותו לאורו ואין חוששין לפתילתו להחליפו עד שיכלה:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
The commandment to kindle it extends from sunset until the last person has left¹⁷ the street.¹⁸ And, although there is no actual proof,¹⁹ there is an allusion to it: *The pillar of cloud by day* [*and the pillar of fire by night*,] *departed not*.²⁰ lamp, was intended to shed light, appeared in the night only If it was lit in daytime, one must derive no benefit from it, nor may the benediction be said over it; for so [the Rabbis] said: No benediction is to be pronounced over the lamp before one enjoys its light. There is no need, however, to be concerned about changing the wick before it has been used up.

footnotes:
¹⁷ lit. ‘the foot ceases from’.
¹⁸ The light is intended to serve as a public demonstration, but at such a late hour there are no passers-by to see it.
¹⁹ That the lighting must take place after sunset.
²⁰ Ex. 13, 22, which indicates that the pillar of fire which, like the Ḥanukkah


###### Tractate Soferim 20:5
[Tractate Soferim 20:5](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:5)

נר חנוכה מצוה להניחו בפתח הסמוך לרה"ר שתהא מזוזה בימין ונר חנוכה משמאל לקיים מה שנאמר (ש"ה ז) מה יפית ומה נעמת מה יפית במזוזה ומה נעמת בנר חנוכה ונרות כב"ה משום מעלין בקדש ולא מורידין כעין ימים היוצאין:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
It is a religious precept to place the *Ḥanukkah* lamp by the door which is near to the public domain,²¹ in such a manner that the *mezuzah* should be on the right hand and the *Ḥanukkah* lamp on the left, to fulfil what is stated, *How fair and how pleasant art thou*²²—*how fair* with the *mezuzah* and *how pleasant* with the *Ḥanukkah* lamp. The number²³ of lights [for each night] is in accordance with the ruling of the School of Hillel,²⁴ because in sacred matters one should proceed to a higher grade²⁵ but not descend to a lower one,²⁶ [and also because the number of lights should] correspond to the days [of the Festival] as they pass.

footnotes:
²¹ So that the light is seen from the street.
²² Cant. 7, 7.
²³ Inserted by GRA, wanting in V, M and H.
²⁴ One light on the first night, two on the second, and so on, until eight lights burn on the eighth and last night of the Festival.
²⁵ Adding lights on the succeeding nights.
²⁶ As would happen if the number were to be reduced from eight on the first night to one on the last in accordance with the view of Beth Shammai.


###### Tractate Soferim 20:6
[Tractate Soferim 20:6](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:6)

וכיצד מברכין ביום ראשון המדליק מברך שלש והרואה מברך שתים בא"י אשר קדשנו במצותיו וצונו להדליק נר ואומר הנרות האלו אנו מדליקין על הישועות ועל הניסים ועל הנפלאות אשר עשית לאבותינו ע"י כהניך הקדושים וכל (מצות) שמונת ימי חנוכה הנרות האלו קודש ואין לנו רשות להשתמש בהן אלא לראותן בלבד כדי להודות לשמך על נפלאותיך ועל נסיך ועל ישועתך בא"י שהחיינו ואומר שעשה נסים לאבותינו אלו למדליק אבל לרואה אינו אומר ביום ראשון אלא שתים שהחיינו ושעשה מכאן ואילך [המדליק] מברך להדליק ושעשה והרואה אומר (אשר עשה) [שעשה] נסים:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
In what manner are the benedictions²⁷ lights. said? On the first day, the person who kindles [the lamp] says three benedictions while the onlooker says two. The person who kindles says, ‘Blessed art Thou, O Lord,²⁸ Who hast sanctified us by Thy commandments and hast given us command to kindle the light of *Ḥanukkah*’. Then²⁹ he says, ‘We kindle these lights on account of the deliverances and the miracles and the wonders which Thou didst work for our fathers, by means of Thy holy priests.³⁰ During all the eight days of *Ḥanukkah* these lights are sacred, and it is not permitted to make any profane use of them but we are only to look at them, in order that we may give thanks unto Thy name for thy wonders, Thy miracles and Thy deliverances’. [The third benediction is] ‘Blessed art Thou, O Lord, Who hast kept us in life’.³¹ [Before this] he says, ‘Who wroughtest miracles for our fathers’.³² These benedictions are for the person who kindles the lights, but the onlooker says on the first day only two benedictions: ‘Who hast kept us in life’ and ‘Who wroughtest miracles’. From that day onwards the person who kindles the lights says, ‘To kindle’ and ‘Who wroughtest’, while the onlooker only says ‘Who wroughtest miracles’.

footnotes:
²⁷ Over the Ḥanukkah
²⁸ Inserting after ‘Lord’, as in all benedictions, ‘our God, King of the universe’ (P.B., p. 274).
²⁹ After the three benedictions: the one just given and the two mentioned below.
³⁰ The Maccabees who were a priestly family.
³¹ Concluding ‘and hast preserved us, and enabled us to reach this season’ (P.B., p. 274).
³² Beginning, as usual, ‘Blessed art … universe’ and concluding ‘in the days of old at this season’ (P.B., p. 274).


###### Tractate Soferim 20:7
[Tractate Soferim 20:7](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:7)

החזן צריך לומר אתה קדוש בשמנה עשר של חנוכה וכן בראשי חדשים וכן בחולו של מועד מפני שכתוב בהן עולת תמיד ותני רבי חייא כל יום שאין בו מוסף אין בו קדוש חוץ מן החנוכה שאע"פ שאין בה מוסף יש בה קדוש מפני (מה) שיש בה הלל וי"א אף בפורים מפני שיש בה מגילה:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
The precentor must say, ‘Thou art holy’³³. It appears that, instead of beginning with ‘We will sanctify’ (P.B., p. 45) or ‘We will reverence’ (P.B., p. 160), there was a custom to begin with ‘Thou art holy’ on Sabbath and Festivals. Rule 7 extends this practice to some of the less important days as specified below. It has also been suggested to read, instead of *’attah ḳadosh* (‘Thou art holy’) *’eth haḳḳedushshah* (‘the *ḳedushshah*’). on the eight days³⁴ of *Ḥanukkah*, and similarly on New Moons and on the intermediate days of a Festival,³⁵ because *beside*³⁶ *the continual burnt-offering*³⁷ 24 (on the intermediate days of Passover); and *ibid.* XXIX, 19, 22, 25, 28, 31, 34 (on those of Tabernacles). is written in connection with them. And R. Hiyya learnt: On any day on which there is a musaf *ḳedushshah* is said except on *Ḥanukkah* on which *ḳedushshah* is said although there is no *musaf* on it, because *Hallel* is included [in the service]. Some maintain [that it is said] on *Purim* also, because the scroll of Esther is read on it.

footnotes:
³³ i.e. the ḳedushshah
³⁴ So GRA. V, M and H read ‘in the eighteen [benedictions]’.
³⁵ viz. Passover and Tabernacles.
³⁶ Inserted by GRA, omitted by V, M and H.
³⁷ Num. 28, 15 (on the New Moon); ibid.


###### Tractate Soferim 20:8
[Tractate Soferim 20:8](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:8)

ואומרים בהודייה והודאת פלאות ותשועת כהנים אשר עשית בימי מתתיהו בן יוחנן כהן גדול וחשמונאי ובניו וכן עשה עמנו ה' אלהינו ואלהי אבותינו נסים ונפלאות ונודה לשמך לנצח בא"י הטוב ונסים מרדכי ואסתר מזכירין אותן בהודייה ושניהן נזכרין בברכת המזון:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
In the benediction for Thanksgiving³⁸ we include [on *Ḥanukkah*] ‘and thanks for the wonders and salvation of Thy priests which Thou hast wrought in the days of Mattathias, son of Joḥanan, High Priest, and the Hasmoneans his sons. So also, O Lord our God and God of our fathers, perform for us miracles and wonders, and we will give thanks unto Thy name for ever. Blessed art Thou, O Lord, Who art all-good’.³⁹ The miracles [of the days] of Mordecai and Esther are also mentioned [on *Purim*] in the benediction for Thanksgiving. Both⁴⁰ and *Purim*. are likewise mentioned in the Grace after meals.⁴¹

footnotes:
³⁸ Beginning ‘We give thanks’ (P.B., p. 51).
³⁹ The present version of this form of thanksgiving is longer and differs in wording (P.B., p. 52).
⁴⁰ Those for Ḥanukkah
⁴¹ In the second benediction (P.B., p. 281).


###### Tractate Soferim 20:9
[Tractate Soferim 20:9](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:9)

וגומרין את הלל כל שמנת ימי חנוכה בג׳ פרקים הראשונים אין משיבין ואין צ"ל לשאול בשנים האחרונים שואלין מפני היראה [ומשיבין] מפני השלום ומפני הכבוד ואלו הן שלשה ראשונים הללו עבדי ה׳ בצאת ישראל אהבתי שנים האחרונים הללו את ה׳ הודו לה׳ וצריך לברך בתחילתן ולקרותן בנעימה דתני ר׳ שמעון בן יהוצדק ימים שמנה עשרה ולילה אחד יחיד גומר בהן את ההלל ואלו הן שמנת ימי חנוכה וי"ט של עצרת וי"ט הראשון של פסח ולילו ובגולה עשרים ואחד יום ושתי לילות מצוה מן המובחר לקרות הלל בשני לילות של גליות ולברך עליהן ולאומרן בנעימה לקיים מה שנאמר (תהילים ל״ד:ד׳) ונרוממה שמו יחדיו וכשהוא קורא אותו בביתו אינו צריך לברך שכבר בירך ברבים:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
The whole *Hallel*⁴² is recited during all the eight days of *Ḥanukkah*. During [the recital of] the first two⁴³ chapters one may not return greetings, and there is no need to say that one must not give greetings. During [the recital of] the last two chapters one may give greetings out of fear;⁴⁴ during the two middle chapters⁴⁵ [greetings may be given] for the sake of peace or out of respect. The following are the first two chapters: *Praise, O ye servants of the Lord*⁴⁶ and *When Israel went forth*.⁴⁷ CXIV. V, M and H adds Ps. 115 as the third. The two middle ones are: *Not unto us*⁴⁸ CXV; ‘the two middle … *us’* is the reading of GRA. and *I love*.⁴⁹ CXVI. The last two are: *O praise the Lord*⁵⁰ CXVII. and *O give thanks unto the Lord*.⁵¹ CXVIII. It is also necessary to say a benediction⁵²’ (P.B., p. 219). before them and read them melodiously. For R. Simeon b. Jehoẓadaḳ said:⁵³ On eighteen days and one night the individual reads the whole *Hallel* and they are: the eight days of *Ḥanukkah*, the eight days of Tabernacles,⁵⁴ the Festival of Solemn Assembly, the first Festival day of Passover and the night preceding it.⁵⁵ was recited during the sacrifice of the Paschal lamb on the eve of Passover.] In the Diaspora⁵⁶ [the whole *Hallel* is read on] twenty-one days and two nights. The most proper way of performing the commandment is to read the *Hallel* psalms on the two nights [of Passover] in the Diaspora in the Synagogue,⁵⁷ ritual. ‘In the Synagogue’ is inserted by GRA but omitted by V, M and H. to say the benediction over them, and to recite them melodiously to fulfil what is stated, *And let us exalt His name together*.⁵⁸ When, however, one reads [the *Hallel*] at home,⁵⁹. there is no need to say the benediction because it has already been said in the congregational service.⁶⁰ in the home.

footnotes:
⁴² Including Pss. CXV, 1-11 and CXVI, 1-11 (P.B., pp. 220f).
⁴³ So GRA. V, M and H read ‘three’.
⁴⁴ To a person who can cause harm in his resentment at not having been greeted.
⁴⁵ The reading of GRA. V and M have ‘and return greetings for the sake of peace and out of respect’. H omits the text of V and GRA.
⁴⁶ Ps. 113.
⁴⁷ ibid.
⁴⁸ ibid.
⁴⁹ ibid.
⁵⁰ ibid.
⁵¹ ibid.
⁵² ‘Blessed art Thou … to read the Hallel
⁵³ So GRA. V, H and M read ‘learnt’ using a term which refers to a Mishnah, whereas the quotation is from the Gemara in Ta‘an. 28b (Sonc. ed., pp. 150f).
⁵⁴ Omitted by V and M, but added by GRA and H in agreement with Ta‘an. loc. cit.
⁵⁵ [Cf. Pes. V, 7 (Sonc. ed., p. 327) where it is described how the Hallel
⁵⁶ i.e. all countries outside the land of Israel where two days are observed as holy instead of the first day of Tabernacles, two days for the Festival of Solemn Assembly, and two days each for the first and seventh day of Passover.
⁵⁷ In addition to reading them at home in the course of the Seder
⁵⁸ Ps. 34, 4.
⁵⁹ During the Seder
⁶⁰ lit. ‘among many’. The Service in Synagogue precedes the Seder


###### Tractate Soferim 20:10
[Tractate Soferim 20:10](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:10)

ואחר כך מוציאין ספר וקורין בנשיאים ויהי המקריב ביום הראשון וכן לכל יום יומו עד יום השמיני ובשבת שבתוכו קוראו ויהי ביום כלות משה עד כן עשה את המנורה וכן ביום השמיני עד וזה מעשה המנורה כל הפסוק ומפטיר בותשלם כל המלאכה (מלכים א ז׳:נ״א):

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
A scroll⁶¹ is then taken out⁶². and we read in the section of the princes,⁶³ *And he that presented his offering the first day was;*⁶⁴ 12-17. and likewise for each day [the corresponding section of the offering] of that day,⁶⁵ day corresponding to the respective number of the days of the offerings of the princes. until the eighth day. On the Sabbath [during *Ḥanukkah*] one reads, *And it came to pass on the day that Moses made an end*⁶⁶ up to *so he made the candlestick*.⁶⁷ VIII, 4. On the eighth day he reads from *On the eighth day*⁶⁸ 54. through all the sections⁶⁹ until *so he made the candlestick*. On the Sabbath⁷⁰ (Num. 8, 4) all the verse’. H has a different text. one also reads as the *hafṭarah, Thus all the work … was finished*.⁷¹

footnotes:
⁶¹ M and H read ‘a scroll of the Torah’.
⁶² In the Synagogue Service during Ḥanukkah
⁶³ Num. 7.
⁶⁴ ibid.
⁶⁵ lit. ‘and so for each day its day’, the number of the Ḥanukkah
⁶⁶ Num. 7, 1.
⁶⁷ ibid.
⁶⁸ ibid.
⁶⁹ Of the offerings of all the princes.
⁷⁰ So GRA. V and M read: ‘and so on the eighth day until And this was the work of the candlestick
⁷¹ i.e. in the passage 1 Kings 7, 51—VIII, 21.


###### Tractate Soferim 20:11
[Tractate Soferim 20:11](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:11)

(אין) מקדימין בשמנת ימי חנוכה לומר ביום השני ביום השלישי ביום הרביעי ביום החמישי ביום הששי ביום השביעי ביום השמיני כדי לגמור עשרה פסוקים:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
During the eight days of *Ḥanukkah* we read the following one day earlier:⁷² *On the second day*,⁷³ *On the third day*,⁷⁴ 24-29. *On the fourth day*,⁷⁵ 30-35. *On the fifth day*,⁷⁶ 36-41. *On the sixth day*,⁷⁷ 42-47. *On the seventh day*,⁷⁸ 48-53. *On the eighth day*,⁷⁹ 54-59. so as to complete ten verses.⁸⁰.

footnotes:
⁷² lit. ‘we advance to say’. To the prescribed reading of the day that of the following day is added.
⁷³ Num. 7, 18-23. This is added to the reading of the first day and then repeated on the second, and similarly with the rest.
⁷⁴ ibid.
⁷⁵ ibid.
⁷⁶ ibid.
⁷⁷ ibid.
⁷⁸ ibid.
⁷⁹ ibid.
⁸⁰ Which is the minimum required for the reading of the three persons who are called to the Torah each day of Ḥanukkah


###### Tractate Soferim 20:12
[Tractate Soferim 20:12](https://torahapp.org/share/book/Tractate%20Soferim/r/20:12)

בזמן שחל ר"ח טבת להיות באחד בשבת ביום ראשון קורין בענין ר"ח תחלה שלשה והרביעי של חנוכה שכל התדיר מחבירו תדיר קודם והוא קודם את חבירו אבל ביום שני אינו כן אלא קורים שלשה בשל חנוכה והרביעי בשל ר"ח שאין חשבון חודש מיום שני אלא בזמן שהשנים כסדרן דר׳ יצחק סחורה שאל את ר׳ יהושע נפחא ר"ח טבת שחל להיות בשבת במה קורין לענין כלות שלמה והמפטיר בשל שבת ור"ח חל להיות בחול קורין ביום הראשון שלשה [בשל] ר"ח [והרביעי] בשל חנוכה [שכל] התדיר מחבירו (תדיר) קודם את חבירו והואיל וקרא תחלה בשל ר"ח ביום השני קורא ג׳ לחנוכה והרביעי בשל ר"ח ובראשי חדשיכם עד שישלים (כל השיטה) ולמה כן שלא בא הרביעי אלא מחמת מוסף של ר"ח הרי מפסיקין לחנוכה:

**The Minor Tractates of the Talmud, trans. A. Cohen, London: Soncino Press, 1965:**
When the New Moon of *Ṭebeth*⁸¹. falls on a Sunday, three persons read on the first day⁸² in the passage of the New Moon first, while the fourth reads the passage of *Ḥanukkah*, because that which is more frequent takes precedence,⁸³ once a year. and so [the reading for the New Moon] precedes the other. On the second day, however, the order is not the same, but three persons read the passage of *Ḥanukkah* while the fourth reads that of the New Moon, because on the previous day the section of the New Moon had been read first.⁸⁴ [This is the procedure] because R. Isaac Seḥorah asked R. Isaac Nappaḥa, ‘Which do we read [first]⁸⁵ when the New Moon of *Ṭebeth* falls on a Sabbath?’ [He replied,] ‘In the section of *kalloth Mosheh*,⁸⁶ (Num. 7, 1). The extent of the reading is given in Rule 10 above. while the *mafṭir* reads⁸⁷ the passages relating to the Sabbath and the New Moon.⁸⁸ If it falls on a week-day, on the first day [of the New Moon] three persons read [the passage] for the New Moon, the fourth reading that of *Ḥanukkah;* because that which is more frequent takes precedence. As, however, the section of the New Moon was read first,⁸⁹ three persons are to be called up on the second day for the reading of the *Ḥanukkah* section,⁹⁰. while the fourth reads⁹¹ the section of the New Moon, viz. *And in your new moons* to the end of the section.⁹² Why is this so?⁹³ Because it is only on account of the *musaf* of New Moon⁹⁴ there is no *musaf*. This argument cannot be applied to the first day of New Moon because it is the second day which begins the month, the first being the last day of the old month. that a fourth person is added.⁹⁵ Behold [we have concluded the regulations respecting] the interruption which is made for the sake of *Ḥanukkah*.⁹⁶

footnotes:
⁸¹ Which always occurs during Ḥanukkah
⁸² Of the New Moon, which is observed sometimes on one day and sometimes on two.
⁸³ The New Moon occurs every month, Ḥanukkah
⁸⁴ So GRA. V, M and H read: ‘because the reckoning of the month is from the second day only when the years are regular’.
⁸⁵ In the second and third scrolls of the Torah. In the first the regular portion of the week is read.
⁸⁶ E.V. Moses had made an end
⁸⁷ In the third scroll.
⁸⁸ Num. 28, 9-15.
⁸⁹ On the first day of New Moon.
⁹⁰ In the first scroll. Only two scrolls are taken out on the week-days of Ḥanukkah
⁹¹ In the second scroll.
⁹² Num. 28, 11-15.
⁹³ Why is the order of the reading reversed on the second day as compared with the first?
⁹⁴ On the other week-days of Ḥanukkah
⁹⁵ Rule 12 incorporates nearly the whole of XII, 7.
⁹⁶ Cf. XVII, 2f.