# When a Recipe Has No Rules

From **R Nosson Hirth: ShiurBank** by R Nosson Hirth.

- **Published:** Sun, 09 Aug 2026 17:00:00 GMT
- **Duration:** 1:59
- **Audio:** https://www.shiurbank.org/feeds/audio/43ce0353-ed16-4b87-a5ae-18f99044b3d8
- **Page:** https://www.shiurbank.org/shiur/43ce0353-ed16-4b87-a5ae-18f99044b3d8?v=11
- **TorahApp:** https://torahapp.org/share/p/SB_nosson-hirth/e/shiurbank%3Ashiur%3A43ce0353-ed16-4b87-a5ae-18f99044b3d8

Can one employ a שינוי by a loose mixture if it's unknown the order of the placement of the ingredients?

Series: Hilchos Shabbos

Speaker: Rabbi Nosson Hirth

Date: 2026-08-09