# Mini-Chabura, daf 11: Is Exile Atonement or Punishment?

From **All: R Ephraim Meth** by R Ephraim Meth.

- **Published:** 2010-06-15T00:00:00Z
- **Duration:** 12:30
- **Books:** Makkot
- **Sections:** 11a, 11b
- **Audio:** https://shiurim.yutorah.net/2010/3772/746024.MP3
- **Page:** https://yutorah.org/lectures/746024
- **TorahApp:** https://torahapp.org/share/p/YU_81188_all/e/yu%3A746024