Text

Chizkuni, Genesis

Can copy this into an AI, or connect the whole library to your assistant. For deeper learning, you can directly use the original seforim, sites, and apps.

ויבאו שני המלאכים פרש״‎י גבי לוט קראם מלאכים. ואם תאמר הא כתיב ויאמרו האנשים אל לוט. אלא ה״‎ק ויאמרו אותם שקראו להם בני העיר אנשים, וכן תפרש, לאותם שקראתם אנשים לא תעשו דבר וכמו כן ויחזיקו האנשים.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ויבאו שני המלאכים, “the two angels arrived, etc.;” Rashi points out that when these two individuals arrived in Eloney Mamre in front of Avraham’s tent, the Torah had referred to them as אנשים, men, mortal human beings, whereas now they are described as angels. If you were to counter that in the ensuing argument between the townspeople and Lot they are also described as אנשים, (verses 5,8,12) this sentence has to be understood as follows: “the ones whom the men of the city called אנשים, “men of substance, etc;” the whole dialogue must be understood thus:Alternately; Lot is saying to his fellow citizens: “do not do any harm to the guests in my house to whom you refer as אנשים. He realised that whereas he had recognised these individuals as angels, his fellow citizens obviously had not. This explanation is also applicable to verse 16, ויחזיקו האנשים, “the men” took hold of, etc.”

ולוט ישב בשער סדם כשפסק התגר חזר למקומו ודירתו אצל השער ולפיכך ויפצר בם מאד כי המקום היה צנוע ואין לדאוג בו מן הפריצים לפי שאין עין הפריצים שולט בו.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ולוט יושב בשער סדום, while Lot was seated (as a judge) in the public square of Sodom;” this was at the time when the quarrel about his guests broke out and he returned home, which was close to the gate of the city. This is why he could be so insistent when inviting the angels (verse 3) as the area was narrow and not exposed to the influence of the evil eye. [No one was familiar with the layout of his house.]

ולינו הכנסו לבית מיד קודם שיתנו בכם עיניהם פריצי העיר שאם תתעכבו חוץ לבית שמא יכירו בכם.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ולינו, “and spend the night (in my house);” he brought them into his house without delay before the people of Sodom could see them, and subsequently could identify them.

ורחצו רגליכם אף זו עשה כשורה אמר אם הללו יהיו נראין באבק שעל רגליהם הרשעים יחקרו היכן לנו.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ורחצו רגליכם, “and wash your feet.” This was an additional precaution, as he reasoned if any of the townspeople will see their dusty feet they will realise that they recently arrived from beyond the city gates. This will cause the townspeople to investigate these men further.

ולינו ורחצו וכי אדם עשוי ללין תחלה ואחר כך רוחץ, ועוד הרי אברהם אמר להם תחלה ורחצו רגליכם, אלא כך אמר לוט אם יכנסו הם לבית אחר רחיצת רגליהם שמא יכירו מקצת פריצי העיר ויראו רגליהם בלא טינוף ויאמרו כבר עברו שלשה ימים שבאו אלו אל ביתך ולא הודעתנו מוטב שיכנסו רגליהם מטונפים ואם יכירו בביאתם יהיו נראים כבני אדם שבאו מיד לפיכך אמר והשכמתם והלכתם לדרככם פן יכירו בכם.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ולינו ורחצו, “spend the night and wash;” an unusual request, as most people wash (their feet) before going to bed at night. Besides we have it on the authority of Avraham who had asked the same men to first wash the dust off their feet before having lunch with him. (18,4) We therefore must understand Lot as follows: “if the men enter the house after having washed their feet, and they are seen as having clean feet, the townspeople will be suspicious believing that Lot had harboured guests secretly for several days already without their knowledge. He reasoned that the lesser evil is having these men sleep with dirty feet for one night than to provoke an altercation with the townspeople. Knowing of this danger, Lot added that the men (angels) should rise early and leave before they could be detected as guests of his.

כי ברחוב נלין כדי שיראו אותנו אנשי העיר שלהפכה באנו אולי ישובו.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

כי ברחוב נלין, “for we will spend the night outdoors.” When the angels realised how scared Lot was to give them shelter for even one night, they declined his invitation, suggesting that they would take care of themselves even when remaining in the street, visible to all. They considered it appropriate to be seen by the people whom they had been sent to destroy together with their miserable city. If they would begin to realise this, perhaps they would become penitents.

מנער ועד זקן מלמד שכולם רשעים לפיכך לא נענה אברהם כשהתפלל על עשרה.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

מנער ועד זקן, “both young and old.” Seeing that all of them were wicked, Avraham had not received an assurance beyond a minimum of ten.

ונדעה אתם למשכב זכר. כמו והאדם ידע את חוה אשתו, ועוד מתשובתו של לוט שאמר הנה נא לי שתי בנות יש להבין שלדבר עבירה היו תובעים אותם להתעלל בהן.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ונדעה אותם, “so that we may engage in homosexual relations with them;” the word ידע is familiar to us from Genesis 4,1 where it described Adam in engaging in carnal relations with Chavah. Besides, it is clear from Lot’s offer of his two virgin daughters as an alternative to satisfy the carnal desires of the men of Sodom (19,8), that these men were planning a criminal activity.

אשר לא ידעו איש היה לו לומר אשר לא ידען איש כדאמר בתולה ואיש לא ידעה אלא מנהג הוא שדרך האיש לפתוח את האשה, אבל בנות לוט פרוצות בעריות היו ודרכן לפתות שכן פיתו את אביהן ולכך כתיב בהן אשר לא ידעו איש וכן בבנות מדין שהיו פרוצות ופיתו את ישראל כתיב בהן וכל אשה יודעת איש.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

אשר לא ידעו איש, “who have not had carnal relations with any man.” According to proper grammar, Lot should have said: אשר לא ידען איש, “with whom no man had had carnal relations;” seeing that it is usually the male who seduces the female; however the daughters of Lot were not chaste and did not shy away from engaging in seducing men, as we know from later when they initiated carnal relations with their own father. (20,33) Their descendants, the daughters of Midian, kept up the tradition when they seduced the Israelite males in the desert (Numbers 31,17) As a result all the female Midianite prisoners who had lost their virginity were not allowed to live.

[רק לאנשים האל לאותם שקראתם להם אנשים]. כי על כן שהרי בשביל שלא תהא להם שום טרדא באו בצל קרתי.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

כי על כן, “for on account of” (their not wishing to be disturbed, they came to my house for shelter).

עתה נרע לך מהם הרי אתה אורח כמותם ונוהג עצמך כבעל הבית.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

עתה נרע לך מהם, “You are a guest here like they are, yet you conduct yourself like a native (citizen).”

[ויאמרו האנשים אותם שבני המקום קראו להם אנשים].

כי משחתים אנחנו בכל שליחות המלאכים כתיב לשון יחיד, שוב אשוב, ויאמר המלט, וכאן כתיב לשון רבים. אלא כיון שבהפיכה מצינו לשון יחיד לבלתי הפכי, מצי נמי למינקט לשון רבים.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

כי משחיתים אנחנו, “for we are about to destroy, etc.” Throughout the mission of the angels they are referred to in the singular mode. (Compare 18,10; 19,17, 19,22) Here the Torah used the plural mode. Why? Seeing that the Torah had used the plural mode (verse 21) it used the same mode here also when the subject is the destruction.

וישלחנו משקל כבד ודגש. אעפ״‎י שכל שליחות שלוחים החוזרים כתיב בהו וישלח מלשון קל ורפי, הכא כתיב משקל כבד ודגש לפי שהוא שלוח של השחתה, דוגמת ושן בהמות אשלח בם. ישלח בם ערוב.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

וישלחנו, “He has sent us;” this word is in the piel conjugation with a dot in the letter ל, although the word normally is used in the conjugation kal and without the dot, when the mission on which the messenger has been sent is a two way mission, i.e. he has to come back with an answer or something tangible before the mission is considered as complete, in this instance we find that the conjugation piel a “strong” conjugation has been used as the mission was one of destruction. Another such example is found in Deuteronomy 32,24: ושן בהמות אשלח בם, “and fanged beasts will I let loose against them.” Still another such example is Psalms 78,45: ישלח בהם ערוב, He dispatched against them wild beasts.”

וכמו השחר עלה פסוק זה נכתב לפי שעתיד לומר השמש יצא על הארץ ולוט בא צוערה, להודיע שכל כך המתינו לו המלאכים לשחת הערים בשביל חיבתו של אברהם אבינו. אמר רבי חנינא משיעלה עמוד השחר עד הנץ החמה חמשה מילין שכן כתיב וכמו השחר עלה וכתיב השמש יצא על הארץ ולוט בא צוערה, ומסדום לצוער חמשה מילין.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

וכמו השחר עלה, “and as dawn was about to rise, etc.” this verse was written as if describing an event in the future, as the Torah wished to portray for how long the angels delayed carrying out their mission involving the dual task of destroying Sodom and saving Lot, the latter not having been completed until after sunrise, as is clear from verse 23 where Lot’s arrival in Tzoar is reported. The angels delayed because of their fondness for Avraham. Rabbi Chanina is quoted as having said (Bereshit Rabbah 50,10) that the time between dawn rising and the sun rising is equivalent to the distance a normal person can walk a distance of about 1200 meters. He used verse 23 as the basis for his statement.

ויציאהו חסר וי״‎ו לומר זה רפאל שהוציא והציל את לוט. [ויחזיקו האנשים אותם שבני המקום קראו להם אנשים].

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ויוציאה, “they took him outside;” there is a letter ו missing before letter ה, to hint that only one angel, i.e. ויוציא, singular, the angel Gavriel, had been charged with the task of saving Lot.

ויהי כהוציאם אתם החוצה היה לו לומר כהוציאם החוצה אלא לימדך הכתוב אותם דוקא הוציאו ולא את ממונם, מלמד שהיה לוט מחזר אחר ממונו להוציאו ולא הניחוהו דוגמת ופגריכם אתם. דבר אחר ויהי כהוציאם המלאכים אתם את לוט ואת ביתו.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ויהי כהוציאם אותם החוצה, “and it was as he took them outside;” the word אותם appears superfluous, as it is included in the plural suffix ם; the reason it was added was to emphasise that the angel only took Lot, his wife and the two daughters who were still unmarried. They were not allowed to take with them any of their belongings. The spelling of the verse is to teach us that Lot was so “married” to his material possessions that he could not face having to become separated from these. We have a similarly strange sounding grammatical formulation in Numbers 14,32: ופגרכם אתם “and you who are living corpses;”An alternate exegesis for the expression: ויהי כאשר הוציאם; the word is not exclusive but inclusive, i.e. “when the angel took Lot and his family out, etc.;”

אל תביט אחריך בשביל צער חתניך שבעיר ורוץ מהרה לדרכך ואל תפסיק להסתכל אנה ואנה כי הענן עולה ובו אש וגפרית ומתפשט בכל הארץ.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

אל תביט אחריך, “literally: “do not look behind you;” the reference is not to what one sees with one’s eyes, but to what one sees with one’s mind’s eye, i.e. leaving behind other members of one’s family. The angel warned Lot to move forward with all possible speed, not allowing any other consideration to slow him down. The reason was that the cloud containing the lethal particles had already risen and was unstoppable. It would discharge its contents all over the region.

אל תביט הזהיר לו ולכל אשר לו ולכך לקתה אשתו. ודוגמא זו מצינו בפרשת בראשית ומעץ הדעת טוב ורע לא תאכל ממנו משמע שלא תאכל אתה וכל אשר לך ולכך לקתה חוה. אל תביט הבי״‎ת נקודה בחירק.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

אל תביט, “do not look!” Although the command is issued in the singular mode, [presumably Lot’s wife and daughters did not qualify for being addressed by an angel. Ed.] the warning was meant for each of the members of Lot’s family also. We find a parallel example of such a formulation in Genesis 2,17: ומעץ הדעת טוב ורע לא תאכל ממנו, where the prohibition to eat from the tree of knowledge is addressed to Adam in the singular mode, although it was intended both for him and his wife. This is the reason why Adam’s wife was punished for eating from it. אל תביט, the letter ב has the vowel chink, (instead of tzeyre.)

אל נא אדני חול הוא זה ולפיכך סיים כאן את הפסוק ואח״‎כ חזר להתפלל להקב״‎ה הנה נא מצא עבדך חן, ולפי המסורת קודש הוא. וכתיב באל״‎ף דל״‎ת.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

אל נא אדוני, “not so my lord.” The word: adoni here is not sacred (attribute of Divinity). This is why the verse ends with this word. Subsequently, Lot turns to G-d, and prays: “seeing that Your servant has found favour in Your eyes, etc. “ (Talmud, Shavuot, 35) According to our tradition, the word אדני is sacred, according to that version, we vocalise the letter נ with a kametz.

פן תדבקני הרעה של הגפרית והמלח והאש המתפשטים עד למרחוק.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

פן תדבקני הרעה, “so that the disaster will not catch up with me.” He was afraid of the brimstone and sulphur that was beginning to spread all around him.

גם לדבר הזה מוסיף על אשר שמעתי להצילך.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

גם לדבר הזה, “also to this request.” This is the angel speaking after Lot reminded him that it was his task to save him. [Lot speaking: “In addition to the mere fact that you have the task to save me, I ask you to delay destruction of Tzoar until I can reach higher ground.”]

המטיר על סדם פרש״‎י שעה שחמה עומדת עם לבנה ברקיע שכן באותו פרק הלבנה חסרה שכבר נכנס פסח ולבנה נראית עם החמה.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

המטיר על סדום, “made it rain on Sodom, etc.” according to Rashi, this occurred at an hour when both the sun and the moon were visible in the sky; according to him the reason was that some of the Sodomites worshipped the sun, others the moon. If both were visible at the time of this disaster, they would all recognise the powerlessness of their deities to protect them against such disasters emanating in the heavenly regions. The basis of this exegesis is that the Torah does not use the immediate past tense, i.e. וימטר, but uses a pluperfect, המטיר, “had made it rain.” The “Passover” had already commenced on the previous evening before the angels had reached Sodom. [Compare 18,12 on the cosmic significance of that night. Ed.]

מאת ה' נמצא בב״‎ר ובתנחומא, הראשון הוא גבריאל דהכי קים לן דההוא שר של אש, והשני הוא הקב״‎ה.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

מאת ה, according to Bereshit Rabbah 51,3, this is to be understood as the angel Gavriel and Hashem dividing the labour; the former set these harmful substances in motion, the region it emanated from was provided by the Lord Himself. [The reason why our sages understand more than one celestial force to have been involved is the connective letter ו at the beginning of the word: 'וה. Ed.] According to an early version of Tanchuma on this verse, the first time the name Hashem is used in this verse it refers to the angel Gavriel, whereas the second time it refers to Hashem Himself.

ויהפך את הערים מהכא משמע שהפיכת סדום קדמה למיתת שרה, ובחלק משמע איפכא דתני התם אליעזר עבד אברהם איקלע לאתרא דסדום ובעו לאסוקי לפוריא אמר להו מיומא דמיתת שרה לא סליקית לפוריא אלמא דמשמע דמיתת שרה קדמה. אלא י״‎ל הא דתני איקלע אליעזר לאתרא דסדום היינו צוער, וצוער לא נתהפכה.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ויהפוך את הערים, “He overturned the cities;” it is clear from this verse that the destruction of these cities preceded Sarah’s death, whereas in the Talmud Sanhedrin 109 we read the opposite. The Talmud there relates; Eliezer the servant of Avraham once passed the place where Sodom had been located. He was invited to rest on a bed. He replied that he had made a vow ever since Sarah had died not to ever rest on a bed again. From this it is clear that Sarah had already died. We therefore have to assume that Eliezer was speaking about the town of Tzoar, one of the satellite towns of Sodom which had been spared by the prayer of Lot.

וצמח האדמה אמר ריב״‎ל עכשיו ילקוט אדם מעפרה של סדום ויתן בערוגה אחרת אינה צומחת.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

וצמח האדמה, “and the vegetation on the ground.” Rabbi Yoshua son of Levi stated that when a person takes soil from a piece of land that once was Sodom and he transplants it, it will never grow anything again.

ותהי נציב מלח במלח חטאה כמו שפרש״‎י לפיכך כשעברה צווי המלאכים לקתה בלקוי סדום. דבר אחר ותבט אשתו מאחריו ותהי כל הארץ נציב מלח שכן גפרית ומלח שרפה כל ארצה.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ותהיא נציב מלח, “she was turned into a pillar of salt;” her punishment fitted her crime, as Rashi has explained. Rashi claims that when her husband asked his wife to give some salt to his guests so that their food would taste better, she absolutely refused by challenging his right to violate the laws of Sodom concerning the entertaining of any guests. (based on B’reshit Rabbah,50,4) *Alternatively, "his wife gazed behind him and it became... - "it" referring to the entire land becoming filled with salt as it says "all its soil devastated by sulfur and salt." (Deuteronomy 29:22)

וישקף על פני סדם לדעת אם נמצאו שם עשרה שיהיו ניצולים.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

וישקף על פני סדום, “he looked down in the direction of Sodom” to see if 10 just people had been found that were deserving of being saved.

אשר ישב בהן לוט באחת מהן. כמו ויקבר בערי הגלעד, ועל עיר בן אתונות.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

אשר ישב בהן לוט, “in which Lot used to live;” he had not lived in all of them but in one of them. We find a similar construction in Judges 12,7, where Yiftach is reported as having been buried “in the cities of Gilead,” and it clearly does not mean that he had been cut up and been buried in different parts of the region of Gilead. [The Book of Judges merely makes the point that any of these cities would have been proud to have provided his grave. Ed.] Compare also Zachariah 9,9: ועל עיר בן אתונות, “and on a male donkey foaled by one of the sheasses.”

כי ירא לשבת בצוער כי לא הניחה המלאך להשחית אף מפני שלא היה ללוט פנאי להמלט ההרה ומשהיה לו פנאי נתיירא פן יהפוך המלאך את העיר.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

כי ירא לשבת בצוער, “for he was afraid of taking up residence in Tzoar.” The angel had saved Tzoar only temporarily until Lot would recover sufficiently to escape to the mountain. As soon as he would have done so, he became afraid that the angel would complete the task of destroying it.

ותשכב את אביה לפי פרש״‎י משמע שעשתה שלא כהוגן. וא״‎ת הא אמרינן בב״‎ק לעולם יקדים אדם במצות שבשביל לילה אחת שקדמה בכירה וכו׳‎ אלא י״‎ל שעשתה יפה במה שקדמה אבל מפתיחת בקשת הזנות ומה שלמדה את אחותה עשתה שלא כהוגן.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ותשכב את אביה, “she had carnal relations with her father;” according to Rashi, what she did was not proper; if you were to argue that we have a statement in the Talmud Baba Kamma 38, according to which her conduct was to teach us that she was praised for being the first of the two sisters to fulfill this commandment, the meaning is that if something inadmissible (basically) has to be undertaken due to circumstances, the person who is the first to do so is given special credit. Rashi criticises the fact that objectively speaking, she committed incest. [According to the rules about incest, as stipulated in Maimonides, gentile daughters are allowed to have carnal relations with their fathers, based on Sanhedrin 58] According to the mechilta, the fact that they found wine in the cave was a sign for them that what they did had heavenly approval. Ed.]

ובקומה נקוד.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

ובקומה, “and when she got up;” there is a dot above this word. [as opposed to the same word when the Torah describes her sister’s breaking off that intimacy with her father. That word is also spelled without the letter ו when describing the completion of the act of the younger sister. Ed.]

ותהרין שתי בנות לוט פרש״‎י שלטו בעצמן והוציאו את עדותן. ה״‎ג בדלית לשון עדות, וראיה מב״‎ר ואלה בתולי בתי עדות בתי. ולא גרסינן ערותן ברי״‎ש. ועוד כי דרך אותו מקום עדות הוא לבתוליהן והיו מזנות ממקום אחר והם מעכו כל כך למטה שהוציאו הבתולים שהוא עדות שלהם.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

.ומהרין שתי בנות לוט, “the two daughters of Lot became pregnant;” According to Rashi, although normally virgins do not become pregnant from the first time they have carnal relations, these two girls had first removed their hymens, so as to enable them to conceive from the first intercourse with a male. [The author refers to an obscure Midrash, according to which the word ervah, used as synonym for genitals, is spelled with the letter ד instead of ר, i.e. instead of עדותן it should be ערותן as their “proof,” that they had been virgins prior to this. This is based on Deuteronomy 22,17 where the mother of a daughter whose newly wedded husband had accused her daughter of not entering marriage as a virgin by saying: “here is the proof that my daughter was a virgin when she married you.” Ed.] At any rate, Lot’s daughters, through tricks known to girls, contorted themselves in a manner that could serve them as “proof” that they had been innocent virgins up to that time.

והצעירה גם היא לרבות שגם הצעירה ילדה זרע מלוכה כאחותה זו נעמה העמונית שיצא ממנה רחבעם.

Chizkuni, translated and annotated by Eliyahu Munk

והצעירה גם היא, “and the younger sister did also give birth to a son;” the reason this is reported in a separate verse, is to signal that her son too would be originator of a family destined to produce kings. A distant descendant of her was Naamah who became the mother of Rechavam, son of Solomon (Talmud Baba Kamma, 38).