Text

Da'at Zekenim on Exodus Chapter 1

Can copy this into an AI, or connect the whole library to your assistant. For deeper learning, you can directly use the original seforim, sites, and apps.

**ואלה שמות הבאים.**והלא כבר באו קודם לכן אלא קודם שמת יוסף לא נתן עליהם מסים משמת נתן עליהם ונעשה כאלו בו ביום באו:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

ואלה שמות וגו....הבאים, “and these are the names, etc........who arrived in Egypt ” why is that verse written in the present tense, seeing that it was quite some time since Yaakov and his sons had arrived in Egypt? They had been there long before the death of Joseph. The reason that they are referred to as new arrivals was that as long as Joseph was alive they did not have to pay any taxes. As soon as he had died they became subject to normal taxation. Therefore they considered that day as if it was the day that they had arrived there. (Sh’mot Rabbah 1,4)

**ויהי כל נפש.**פי' עם יוסף שהיה במצרי' הי' שבעי' ואז לא יצטרך למנות יוכבד שנולדה בין החומו' מהר"ר שלמה בן פרחון ז"ל, לכך מנאן עכשו אע"פ שמנאן בחייהן לפי שהיה ר"ל אחר כן וירבו ויעצמו להודיע לך שארבעים [ששבעים] נפש לבד עצמו ורבו עד שש מאות אלף רגלי:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

'ויהי כל נפש וגו, “the total number of people, etc;” the number seventy includes Joseph who had already been in Egypt. When you accept this explanation, you do not need to consider Yocheved as having been conceived in the land of Canaan and having been born at the crossing point into Egypt. (Attributed to Rabbi Shlomoh ben Parchon) This is also the reason why their number is repeated here although the Torah had given details already when it described Yaakov’s departure for Egypt in Genesis chapter 46. The purpose of repeating it here is to demonstrate the phenomenal increase in the numbers of Hebrews beginning with their arrival there. Forty male Hebrews who had arrived there increased to over 600000 in the space of 210 years. (Sh’mot Rabbah 1,7)

**ובני ישראל וכו'.**מלמד שהיו יולדות ששה בכרס אחד ורמז מדכתיב ו' לישני פריה ורביה פרו וישרצו וירבו ויעצמו במאד מאד. ד"א כי פרו וישרצו עולה בגי' ששה בכרס אחד פחות שנים וה"נ במאד מאד משלימות החשבון. ד"א פרו שהן עושין פירות וישרצו כשרצים ששה בכרס וא"ת שמתים לכך נאמר וירבו וא"ת חלשים היו לכך נאמר ויעצמו במאד מאד ולכך כתיבי כל הני לישני יתירי:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

'ובני ישראל וגו, and the children of Israel multiplied etc.” according to Sh’mot Rabbah 1,8 this is a hint that Jewish women gave birth to sixtuplets, [or according to a different interpretation of that Midrash, that they became pregnant in much more frequent cycles so that they gave birth six times within a nine month period. Ed.] The six words in the verse all relating to multiplying are understood as a hint of this. If you were to think that many of these infants did not survive, the Torah writes: “they multiplied,” i.e. they all grew up normally.

**ויקם מלך.**הוא פרעה הראשון. אמרו לו בא ונזדווג על אומה זו אמר להם עד עתה אנו חיין משלהם היאך נזדווג להם ולא שמע אליהם הורידוהו מכסאו שלשה חדשים כיון שראה כך אמר להם אשמע לכם לכך כתיב ויקם.

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

ויקם מלך חדש, “a new king (dynasty) arose;” this was the first Pharaoh. The Egyptians suggested to him to join the Hebrews politically. The king said to them, how can we do this, seeing that thus far we have prospered thanks to them? The Egyptians did not like this and removed this new king from the throne for a period of three months. After the three months had elapsed, the king told the people that he was willing to change his attitude on the subject and to oppose the Hebrews. This is why the Torah wrote the word ויקם מלך חדש, “a new king;” The Torah did not report that the old king had died, as is customary.(Sh’mot Rabbah 1,8)

**אשר לא ידע את יוסף.**אמר רבי יהודה בן לוי משל למי שרגם איקונין של מלך נטלוהו והתירוהו למחר רגם את המלך עצמו כך פרעה בתחלה אמר אשר לא ידע את יוסף ולבסוף אמר לא ידעתי את ה':

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

אשר לא ידע את יוסף, “who had not known Joseph.” Rabbi Yehudah ben Levi understands this line as a parable. There was someone who insulted the picture of the King. Having gotten away with that, the following week he insulted the king himself. The new king began by insulting the Jews, and when successful, proceeded to insult the G–d of the Jews. (Compare Sh’mot 5,20)

**הבה נתחכמה לו.**הב"ה בגימטריא י"ב נתחכמה לי"ב שבטים. ופרש"י נתחכם למושיען של ישראל וכו' והם טעו כי לא נשבע אלא שלא יביא מים על האומות אבל שלא יבואו האומות במים לא נשבע. ואמרו חז"ל שלשה היו באותה עצה בלעם ואיוב ויתרו בלעם שיעץ נהרג איוב ששתק נדון ביסורים יתרו שברח זכו בניו לישב בלשכת הגזית ובלעם דהוה בעצת דהבה נתחכמה קשה מהא דאמרינן בפ' חלק בר תלתין ותלת שנין הוה בלעם חגירא כד קטל יתיה פנחס ליסטאה משום דכתיב אנשי דמים ומרמה לא יחצו ימיהם ואם היה בעצה זו נמצא היה בן מאה וארבעים כשנפל במלחמת מדין שהרי לכל הפחות היה בן עשרים כשיעץ ותחשוב שמנים של משה ולסוף ארבעים שהלכו במדבר היתה מלחמת מדין כדכתיב אחר תאסף הרי שהיה בן ק"מ שנה. לכך פי' ר' מנחם מדאנ"י שלשה היו באותה עצה דלכה איעצך כדאמרינן אמר ליה לבלק אלהיהם של אלו שונא זמה הוא כדאי' בחלק והקשה הרב משה כי בדברי הימים דמשה תמצא כתיב בפי' העצה דהכא ויען בלעם הקוסם ועל כן הקשה ר' מנחם מהא דאמרינן בזבחים פרק פרת חטאת בשעה שנתן הקב"ה תורה לישראל נתקבצו כל האומות אצל בלעם ואמרו מה קול ההמון ששמענו שמא הקב"ה רוצה להביא מבול כדאיתא התם. ואפי' אם תמצא לו' שלא היה כי אם בן כ' כששואלין ממנו עצה ובסוף ארבעים נהרג אלמא בן ששים היה כשמת. ויש ספרים שכתוב בהן ונקבצו כלן אצל קמואל והני פי' לא נהירא לי דהתם משמע דקמואל אבי ארם היינו בלעם אם כן תפל היה במיתתו. וגם נמצא בב"ר קמואל אבי ארם הוא לבן הארמי הוא כושן רשעתים הוא בלעם ולמה נקרא קמואל שקם על אומתו של אל. וכן נמי אמרינן בחלק הוא בלע' הוא בעור ולמה נקרא בעור שבא על בעירו הוא לבן הוא כושן רשעתים ולמה נקרא שמו כושן רשעתים שעשה שתי רשעיות אחת בימי יעקב ואחת בימי שופטים מכל אלה משמע שהיה תפל והאי דכתיב באיוב כי יתרי פתח ויענני ובמסורת כתיב יתרו ומפרש דה"ק יתרו נמי היה באותו עצה והוא פתח הדבר ואותי תענה וקשיא דהא דאמרינן דיתרו ברח ואיוב לא ברח אלא שתק וי"ל שהיה יתרו גדול הדור באותה שעה והיה בידו למחות ולא לברוח ולכך מאשימו איוב:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

הבה נתחכמה לו, “let us try to outwit it” (the Jewish nation). The numerical value of the letters in the word הבה , is 12. What the king meant was to outsmart the twelve tribes of the Jewish people. According to Rashi, what the king meant was to outsmart the deity of the Jewish people. How did he think to accomplish this? Seeing that G–d had promised never to bring another deluge, and His method is to match the punishment to the crime, he thought that by drowning Jews in water, G–d would not be able to punish him appropriately. (Talmud, tractate Sotah, folio11). Our sages say that the king had three advisors who helped him figure out how to deal with the ever increasing number of Israelites. They were: Bileam, Job, and Yitro. Bileam was killed for having given the advice the king accepted. Job was subjected to severe afflictions. He had not disagreed, but kept silent on the king’s proposal. Yitro who left that meeting and decided to flee, was rewarded by some of his descendants eventually being able to make their home near the Temple. (Talmud, tractate Sanhedrin, folio 106, quoting Chronicles I 2,55.) According to the Talmud there, Bileam was only thirty three years old when Pinchas killed him during the punitive campaign against Midian reported in Numbers chapter 31. Our author, not surprisingly, questions the statement in the Talmud, seeing that if Bileam had been an advisor to the Pharaoh of whom the Torah speaks here, as that conversation took place before Moses was born and Moses was 119 years old when the campaign against Midian was fought. This is why Rabbi Menachem interprets the statement that when Bileam said to Balak in Numbers 24,14 before taking his leave: לכה איעצך, “I will now give you an advice,” and the Torah does not spell out what the advice was, but writes only what the Israelites will do to the Moabites in the distant future, that what he told him was that seeing the G–d of the Jewish most detests sexual promiscuity, he should arrange for the men of the Israelites to be seduced. (Compare Sanhedrin folio 106) As to the question raised by Rabbi Moshe that this advice of Bileam has been spelled out in the history of Moses’ life and been attributed there to the sorcerer Bileam, (compare a text quoted by Ibn Ezra on Exodus,2,22 and described by him as unreliable. Ed) Rabbi Menachem, quotes the Talmud tractate Zevachim folio 116 that at the time when G–d was ready to give the Torah to the Jewish people, all the gentile nations assembled around Bileam, fearful that another deluge was in the offing. They based themselves on the overwhelming sounds emanating from Mount Sinai at that time, as described in Exodus 19,16. Even if you were to assume that at that time Bileam was no older than twenty years of age, and that he was killed 40 years later during the campaign against Midian, i.e. when he was 60 years old, he clearly had not yet been born when the Pharaoh in our chapter of the Torah consulted how to stop the expansion of the Israelites in Egypt. There are books in which it is claimed that the gentile nations assembled around a person known as Kemuel, whom they asked about the imminence of another deluge. This interpretation is also not plausible, seeing that Kemuel was the founding father of the nation of Aram (Genesis 22, 21, who was a contemporary of Avraham and would have been over 500 years old at his death. Besides, according to B’reshit Rabbah, near the end of paragraph 57, this Kemuel is identified with Lavan, also identical with Kushan Rishatayim, i.e. Bileam. The reason given why he was also known as Kemuel, is that he rebelled against G–d his Creator. This comment is also listed in Sanhedrin folio 105. Why was Bileam’s father called בעור? This was because he had sexual relations with his she-ass, i.e. בעירו. He was also identical with Lavan, who was also known as כושן רשעתים, having been guilty of two sins, one in the days of Yaakov and one in the era of the Judges. From all this it is clear that he was תפל, someone of no value. This is the meaning of Job 30,11 כי יתרי פתח ויענני, “for the Lord has humbled me.” In the version by the Massoretes, the word יתרי is spelled יתרו, a reference to Moses’ father-in-law who had been present when Pharaoh consulted with his advisers how to deal with what he considered the danger of the multiplying Hebrews. Supposedly, he was the first to respond to Pharaoh’s question. This is difficult, as Job never fled, so how can we interpret the beginning of that verse in Job as applying to Yitro? We may have to answer that at that time Yitro was the most respected personage and he could have protested Pharaoh’s murderous intentions, but instead he was content to simply flee Pharaoh’s presence. This is why in the verse quoted Job accuses him of having failed.

**ערי מסכנות.**על שם שכל העוסק בבנין מתמסכן ולשון מסכן הוא ויש לומר שמסכנות האומנין שעומדים כמה פעמים בסכנה על גבי הבנין.

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

ערי מסכנות, “cities for storing goods.” In the Talmud, tractate Sotah folio 11, there are two opinions offered concerning the word מסכנות, One derives it from סכנה, hazard, danger, and accordingly concludes that anyone engaging in building something endangers himself. The other opinion derives it from מסכן, a poor person, suggesting that Pharaoh’s objective was to impoverish the Hebrews by making them do this kind of labour.

פיתום ורעמסס פי' תהום בולע הבנין.

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

פיתום, name of one of the cities the Hebrews built; according to the Talmud there, so named as it was built near an abyss, threatening to bury its builders.

רעמססראשון ראשון מתמוסס ומתמוטט וק"ל דכתב בפרך בפה רך בתחלה אמר להם פרעה לכל אחד מכם אני נותן מכל לבנה שיעשה ובאו כלן ודחקו עצמן מפני חמוד השכר ועשו יותר מדאי וכיון שראה פרעה כך אמר להם השלימו חקכם ללבון כאשר בהיות שכר נתן לכם:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

רעמסס, name of the second city, symbolising the fact that the first city they had built had completely collapsed. Our author has difficulty in understanding this interpretation, seeing that the Torah had described the building of having been the result of פרך, understood as an acronym for פה רך, ‘with a soft tongue,’ i.e. Pharaoh having lured the Hebrews to volunteer to build fortifications, appealing to their patriotism, etc., before gradually becoming far more demanding. At the beginning he paid for each brick made, so that the Hebrews stood in line to participate in the project.

**וימררו.**ובאותו פרק נולדה מרים ועל שם כך נקרא' מרים:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

וימררו, “they embittered” (the lives of the Hebrews) during that period Miriam was born, her name commemorating that period.

**בחמר.**בתחלה:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

בחמר, “with mortar;” at the beginning only this aspect of the labour was conducted with pressure; eventually, everything the Hebrews had to do was done under constant pressure by taskmasters.

**ובכל עבודה.**בסוף:

**למילדות.**רב ושמואל ח"א אשה ובתה יוכבד ומרים וח"א כלה וחמותה. יוכבד ואלישבע: ד"א למילדת חסר וי"ו למד שלא היתה כי אם מילדת אחת והיינו יוכבד אבל מרים נערה היתה ולא היתה מילדת אלא פועה לילד ולכך אמרו חז"ל פועה זו מרים מהרב משה כהן. ד"א שפועה לילד בבטן וקוראה לו צא והוא יוצא:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

למילדת “to the midwife;” there is a disagreement in the Talmud regarding the identity of these two women. According to one opinion they were Yocheved and her daughter Miriam. According to the second opinion, they were mother-in- law Yocheved, and her daughter-in-law. Elisheva, wife of Aaron. (Talmud Sotah, folio 11) An alternate interpretation: this interpretation takes its cue from the fact that the Torah spelled the word מילדת in the singular mode instead of with the letter ו, seeing that there were two women. According to the spelling there was only a single midwife, Yocheved. Miriam was a teenager not capable yet of acting as a midwife, rather she acted as a bleater, to help the infant cry while still inside its mother’s womb encouraging it to emerge from the womb as fast as possible.

**וייטב אלהים.**פרש"י מהו הטובה ויעש להם בתים ולא נראה כי יש פסוק מפסיק ולכן נראה לומר דקאי אאותו פסוק עצמו והפירוש וייטב אלהים למילדות ממה שוירב העם ויעצמו כי לפי שאמרו המילדות לפרעה כי חיות הנה ואינן צריכות אותנו היה אומר פרעה שקרניות הם וכשראה כי רבו העם ויעצמו מאד חזר ואמר כן המילדות דוברות כי ברור לי כי חיה אחת או שתים אינן מספיקות עם רב כזה:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

וייטב אלוקים, “G–d dealt well, etc.” Rashi explains this as a reference to the “houses” that G–d built for the midwife. This does not sound plausible, seeing that there is a whole verse between that statement and this verse. We must understand this statement as referring to something in our verse, i.e. the continued increase in the number of Hebrews. When the midwife(es) had told Pharaoh that the Jewish women were so lively that they had no need for midwives to assist them, Pharaoh had called them liars. When Pharaoh realised this, he was forced to agree that a single or even two midwives would not be able to suppress the increase of the Jews in Egypt.

**ויהי כי יראו המילדות.**פי' כשראה פרעה שלא היו מקיימין מצותו ויעש להם בתים אצל עבדיו כדי שיראו אם הולכות אצל העבריות:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

ויהי כי יראו המילדות, “as a result of the midwives displaying that they were G–d fearing, etc. instead of obeying Pharaoh’s commands, he established houses where they had to check in and report on their activities.

Next →