Da'at Zekenim on Genesis Chapter 48
Can copy this into an AI, or connect the whole library to your assistant. For deeper learning, you can directly use the original seforim, sites, and apps.
**ויאמר ליוסף.**אז"ל זה אפרים ואומר הרב משה זכר לדבר כי אותיות ויאמר כאותיות אפרים בהתחלף דוא"ו בפ"א דא"ו מתחלפת בפ"א באלפא ביתא דא"ת ב"ש ומשמע שלא היה יוסף רגיל אצל יעקב כמו שמצינו נמי ויקרא לבנו ליוסף ושמעתי מפי הרב ר' שמואל ז"ל הטעם לפי שהיה ירא שישאל לו הענין היאך הורד למצרים ויגיד לו שמכרוהו אחיו ויקללם יעקב ונמצא מחריב את העולם כולו שהרי רחל אמו שקלל שלא מדעת ואמר עם אשר תמצא נתקיימה קללתו ומתה בדרך אפרת הא אם יקללם מדעת לא כל שכן:
ויאמר ליוסף, “he said to Joseph;” according to our sages, the subject in this verse was Ephrayim, who informed his father of Yaakov’s illness; (Tanchuma section 6 on this portion) Rabbi Moshe adds that there is an oblique hint of this in the text, seeing that the letters in the word ויאמר and the word אפרים when reading the alphabet backwards, starting with the letter ת, are in the relative same position as when read from the right to left, i.e. the letter ו in the word ויאמר is the sixth letter in the alphabet when read from right to left, whereas the letter פ is in the sixth place when the alphabet is read from left to right commencing with the latter ת. (the other letters are identical) What we learn from this is that whereas Joseph was not a frequent visitor in the province of Goshen where his father resided, his sons spent much more of their time with their grandfather, so that they were aware of any changes in the state of his health. The words ויקרא לבנו ליוסף, “he called for his son, for Joseph,” i.e. sent a messenger to ask for his presence, indicated that he did not want to wait for Joseph’s next visit. I have heard from Rabbi Sh’muel of blessed memory that the reason that Joseph did not frequently visit his father was that he was afraid that Yaakov would ask him how he had come to be in Egypt in the first place, in which case he would have had to tell him that his brothers had sold him, etc., as a result of which his father would have cursed the brothers. This in turn would have spelled the destruction of the civilised world, seeing that when he had cursed Rachel quite unintentionally, Rachel died prematurely as a result, although the teraphim of Lavan had never even been found. We cannot even imagine what the result of Yaakov cursing ten of his twelve sons would have meant.
**ויתחזק ישראל.**ולא רצה לברכם כשהוא במטה שלא יאמר מתנת שכיב מרע היתה ברכתו ולא היה מיושב בדעתו:
ויתחזק ישראל, “Israel strengthened himself.” He did not wish to bless his sons while bedridden, as he said that the blessing of a person clearly on the brink of dying, would not be considered as having been given by someone in possession of all his faculties.
**אפרים ומנשה.**אפרים ומנשה עולין בגימט' ראובן ושמעון אחד יותר:
אפרים ומנשה כראובן ושמעון יהיו לי, “Ephrayim and Menashe shall be for me as possessing the same status as Reuven and Shimon.” It is notable that the numerical value of the words כראובן ושמעון יהיו לי, are identical to the numerical value of אפרים ומנשה [with a difference of only “1, the former amounting to “1” more.” Ed.]
**ויוצא יוסף אותם מעם ברכיו.**לפי שהיו דבוקים לו כשחבקן ונשקן ועכשיו רצה יוסף לסדר כדי שיניח ידו עליהם לכך הוצרך להוציאם מעם ברכיו ולהרחיקם מעט לשום אותם האחד לידו האחת והאחר לידו האחרת:
ויוצא יוסף אותם מעם ברכיו, “and Joseph brought them out from between his knees.” He did so as they had cleaved to their grandfather physically and had kissed him and embraced him. Joseph now wished them to assume a dignified posture to enable Yaakov to place his hands on their heads. Each one should receive his blessing while Yaakov had one hand on the head of each one of them.
**שכל את ידיו.**פי' מתוך מעשה ידיו של יוסף שנתן מנשה לשמאלו שהוא ימין ישראל שכל יעקב את ידיו כי מנשה הבכור ואעפ"כ שם ימינו על ראש אפרים ודומה לו לה' אלהינו הרחמים והסליחות כי מרדנו בו:
שכל את ידיו, seeing that Joseph had lined them up with Menashe on Yaakov’s right side, he was forced to cross his hand in order to give Ephrayim his blessing with his right hand. Although Menashe was Joseph’s firstborn son, Yaakov wished to place his right hand on the head of Ephrayim. We encounter a similar situation in the Book of Daniel,9,9 [where the author recalls G–d’s merciful attitude of forgiving before even having mentioned why that forgiveness was required. Ed.]
**ויקרא בהם שמי ושם אבותי.**על שאר השבטים הנקראים בני יעקב שיהיו נקראים שבטים כשאר בני:
ויקרא בהם שמי ושם אבותי, “and let my name be known through them together with the name of my fathers;” He prayed that just as the 12 tribes who were physical sons of Yaakov were described as his sons, so these two grandsons should also be described as his sons.
**וירע בעיניו.**מפי רבי יצחק לוי שלכך הרע בעיני יוסף שאמר בלבו אבי מחזיק אותי כשוטה שלא סדרתי אותם כהוגן ואני סדרתי אותם כסדר:
וירע בעיניו, “it displeased him (Joseph).” I heard from Rabbi Levi Yitzchok that the reason that Joseph was displeased was that he thought that he, Joseph, was a fool not to have known in which order to position his sons for the blessing, whereas he had done so correctly.
**וישם את אפרים לפני מנשה.**ואימתי נתקיימה ברכתו בחנכת הנשיאים שאפרים הקריב ביום שביעי ומנשה ביום שמיני לקיים מה שנאמר מקים דבר עבדו:
וישם את אפרים לפני מנשה, “thus he placed Ephrayim ahead of Menashe.” When did this blessing and its order become fulfilled, historically? When you look at the consecration rites for the Tabernacle in the desert, in Numbers 7,48, you will find that the prince of Ephrayim presented his offering ahead of the tribe of Menashe, who did so only in verse 54 of that chapter. In this way the statement in Isaiah 44,26, that G–d fulfils the words of his servant, was fulfilled. (B’reshit Rabbah, 97,5)
**ואני נתתי לך.**הקשה הרב רבי משה והלא מטיל קנאה ביניהם והוא היה יודע שבשביל משקל שני סלעים מלת שהוסיף לו על אחיו נתגלגל הדבר וירדו למצרים. וגם על יוסף יש תימה שנתן לבנימין שלש מאות כסף וחמש חליפות שמלות ולאחרים לא נתן אלא חליפות שמלות. ותירץ כי מה שנתן יעקב ליוסף בעודו הדיוט וקטן בזה היו מתקנאים בו כי היה נראה להם שלא היה לו לכבדו יותר מפני שהם גדולים ממנו אבל עכשיו שהיה מלך לא היו מתקנאים שהדין לכבדו מפני כבוד המלכות, וגם שנתקיימו החלומות והיו צריכים לו וגם מה שהיה יוסף מכבד לבנימין יותר מהם לא היו מתקנאים כי אמרו הדין עמו לפי שהוא בן אמו. אמנם מה שריבה משאות בנימין קשיא לי כי אז היו סבורין שלא יהא מכיר אותו והלא היה מטיל קנאה בסעודה ביניהם ונ"ל שגם בזה היו סבורים שהדין עמו לפי שאמר להם להביאו ויש לו לחבבו יותר מן האחרים. ועוד נ"ל כי מאותה שעה היה דעתו של יוסף להתגלות לאחיו וכשידעו שהוא בן אמו לא יתקנאו בו. ויש מפרשים שכם אחד היינו קבר שבשכם כדכתיב ואת עצמות יוסף קברו בשכם משל לגנבים שגנבו חבית מלאה יין ומצאם בעל החבית אמר להם בחסדכם לאחר שתשתו היין החזירו החבית למקומה כך יוסף בשכם גנבוהו ובשכם החזירוהו בעצמות:
ואני נתתי לך, “I have given (allocated) to you;” Rabbi Moshe raises the point that Yaakov was directly responsible for fuelling jealousy between the brothers, commencing already with giving his son Joseph a garment that was visibly more expensive than those worn by his brothers. On account of this error in judgment, the whole family descended to Egypt, only to become enslaved for hundreds of years after initially having been welcomed there. (Compare Talmud, tractate Shabbat folio 10) We must also marvel that Joseph followed in his father’s footsteps by giving his full brother Binyamin far more valuable gifts than he gave to his other brothers (Genesis 45,22). In order to answer these questions we must remember that what Yaakov gave to Joseph was done while he was relatively young and immature, younger than 17 years old, an age at which Ishmael in Genesis 21,14 has still been described by the Torah as a ילד, “a child;” at that time the brothers who were jealous of him had reason to be so. What had he done to deserve preferential treatment by his father? Now that his dreams had come true, not only did they not feel jealous of him, but they were grateful and proud of his achievements. Moreover, they had become economically dependent upon him. Even if he had not treated them well, they were legally obligated to honour him on account of his position. If he gave Binyamin more gifts, that was easily explained by the fact that he was his only full brother. However, what bothers me is that at a time when he had not yet revealed to the brothers who he was, (Genesis 43,34) the brothers of Binyamin must have asked themselves for the reason that this ruler of Egypt who had –according to their assumption- never previously laid eyes on Binyamin, should have given him five times as much as he gave to them. Surely, this would have aroused the other brothers’ jealousy of Binyamin. However, the brothers found a reason for this also, as they considered it as Joseph compensating Binyamin for having insisted that he make the journey to Egypt just because he had not trusted the brothers’ statement that he even existed. Furthermore, I believe that Joseph, already at that point, had decided to reveal his true identity. He was certain that as soon as they would find out that he, Joseph, was a full brother of Binyamin, they would not begrudge him the additional gifts. Some commentators explain the words: שכם אחד, in our verse, the extra portion of ancestral parts of the land of Israel, allocated by Yaakov to Joseph, as referring to the grave in that city in which the remains of Joseph would be interred after the Israelites taking over that country. (Compare Joshua 24,32) The matter can be compared to a parable of thieves who had robbed the owner of a vineyard of a full casket of wine when they were found out by the owner. That owner asked the thieves to do him one favour; seeing that they had already emptied the casket of its contents he asked them to at least return the empty casket to him. Joseph had been sold in Sh’chem. The time had come to at least bring his remains back there. (Compare B’reshit Rabbah, 85,3).