Text

Da'at Zekenim on Leviticus Chapter 16

Can copy this into an AI, or connect the whole library to your assistant. For deeper learning, you can directly use the original seforim, sites, and apps.

**אחרי מות.**זש"ה כטוב כחוטא, כטוב אלו שני בני אהרן שלא מתו אלא מפני שהורו הלכ' בפני משה רבן כדאיתא ביומא. כחוטא זה קרח ועדתו אלו נשרפו ואלו נשרפו אמר ר' אחא בר זעירא זהו שאמר איוב אף לזאת יחרד לבי ויתר ממקומו לא היו בניו של אהרן דומין למטה שהרי המט' נכנס לפני ולפנים יבא לח שנאמר ויוצא פרח. וגם טיטוס הרשע נכנס בשלום ויצא בשלום ובני אהרן נכנסו בשלום ויצאו שרופים זש"ה בחוריו אכלה אש ובתולותיו לא הוללו למה בחורי בני אהרן אכלה אש לפי שבתולות לא הוללו שהרי כמה בתולות נאות יושבות עגונות וממתינות להם והם אמרו אחי אבינו מלך אבינו כהן גדול אחי אמנו נשיא אנחנו סגני כהונה אי זו אשה ההוגנת לנו ולכך לא נשאו ומתו בלא בנים ונ"ל דהיינו דמהדר קרא וימותו כלומר בלא זכרון:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

אחרי מות, “after the death;” when we read in Kohelet 9,2: כטוב כחוטא, “as is the good man so is the sinner,” this is a reference to the two sons of Aaron who died only on account of having arrogated to themselves the right to preempt their elders Moses and Aaron in issuing a religious ruling. This is the meaning of the Talmud, tractate Yuma, folio 53, where Rabbi Eliezer explained the word חוטא as referring to their having done so. What precisely was the “new” ruling that they revealed? They interpreted the line: ונתנו בני אהרן הכהן אש על המזבח, ”the sons of Aaron the priest placed fire (man made) on the altar;” (in addition to the fire that came down from the heaven). (Leviticus 1,7) Their sin was basically the same as that of Korach and his congregation, and that is why both were burned to death by heavenly fire. (Compare Tanchuma on our portion, section 1) Rabbi Acha son of Ze-ira adds (in the Tanchuma) that this is also the meaning of Job 37,1: אף לזאת יחרד לבי ויתר ממקומו, “also on account of this my heart quakes and leaps from its place;” he compares what happened to the staff of Aaron when it was placed inside the Sanctuary which sprouted almonds, whereas his sons when they entered the Sanctuary were burned to death. (Numbers 17,23) He also contrasts the fact that the Roman general Titus dared to enter the Holy of Holies, and he left it unharmed although surely he was less qualified to have entered such sacred grounds. He had entered in order to blaspheme, whereas the sons of Aaron had entered in order to offer incense to the Lord. (Tanchuma section 4 on our portion) [No wonder at the reaction of Job when he reflected on this phenomenon. Ed.] This phenomenon is also the subject of Psalms 78,63: בחורי אכלו אש ובתולותיו לא הוללו, “Fire consumed their young men and their maidens remained unwed.” The psalmist explains the reason that the sons of Aaron had to die as being that they had failed to get married. They had described themselves as so superior that no one was good enough to become their wives. They overestimated the value of having been born into such prominent families as their father and uncle. The result of their haughtiness was that they died without leaving behind any children. (Tanchuma section 6) In other words, no one remembered them.

**בזאת.**רמז לבית ראשון שיתקיים ת"י שנים בגי' של בזא"ת:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

בזאת, “herewith, etc.” the numerical value of the word בזאת is 410, a reminder of the number of years Solomon’s Temple was operative before the last two tribes went into exile.

**גורל אחד לה' כו' לעזאזל.**כתב הרב אברהם בן עזרא ז"ל כשתגיע לשלשים ושלש תדענו וה"פ כשתגיע לגל עד שעולה בגי' ל"ג תמצא לו דומה שאותה תיבה מתחלקת לשנים כלומר גל עד בד בד והכא נמי תחלק האי תיבה לשנים לעז אזל וזהו שעיר המשתלח שהולך לעז לצוק ההר שהוא עז הולך מתרגמינן אזל:

Daat Zekenim translated by Rb. Eliyahu Munk

גורל אחד לה' וגורל אחד לעזאזל, “one lot for the Lord and one lot for Azazel.” Ibn Ezra, [at the conclusion of his commentary on this verse, Ed.], writes that when we get to thirty three, we will be able to understand the meaning of this procedure. [At the beginning of his commentary, he had already hinted that there is a mystical element, kabbalah, in all this. Ed.] What he meant was that when we count the next thirty three verses in the Torah and we get to Leviticus 17,7, the Torah will explain that the procedure described here is meant to teach us not to sacrifice to Satanic forces in the universe anymore. These Satanic forces are symbolised by the scapegoat. Just as the bird released into the air by the priest performing the ritual of the person afflicted with tzoraat is perceived as taking away his former sins, so the scapegoat is supposed to do this on behalf of the whole Jewish nation on the day of Atonement. Ibn Ezra understands the word עזאזל as a combination of two words, similar to גלעד in Genesis 31,47 or to בנימין in Genesis 35,18 or ראובן in Genesis 29,32, and many others. Whereas the first male goat is offered to the Lord as a burnt offering, the second one is symbolically tendered of the Satanic forces, the complete destruction of that animal pointing at the uselessness of idolatry The two words לעז אזל, “it went to waste, to destruction ” symbolise this concept.

Next →