Ibn Ezra on Isaiah Chapter 11
Can copy this into an AI, or connect the whole library to your assistant. For deeper learning, you can directly use the original seforim, sites, and apps.
ויצא וגו'. רובי המפרשים אמרו כי זה המשיח, והטעם שימות מחנה אשור הצר על ירושלם, ועוד יבא עת גאולת ירושלם השלימה, ולפי דעת רבי משה הכהן שעל חזקיהו רמז, כי הוא דבק עם הפרשה:
The majority of commentators apply this chapter to the Messiah, as if the prophet said, The Assyrian army, which is now attacking Jerusalem, will perish; but besides this partial deliverance, a time of complete redemption will come for Jerusalem. R. Moses Hakkohen refers the chapter to Hezekiah, on account of its being the continuation of the prophecy recorded in the preceding chapter.¹
footnotes: ¹ Ibn Ezra does not directly decide in favour of either opinion, but tries throughout the chapter to show that both views can be fairly upheld. The connection with the preceding chapter, however, which is to recommend the view of R. Moses Hakkohen, is a very feeble support, since the transition from momentary relief to the lasting Messianic redemption, even in one and the same chapter, would be quite natural.
חוטר. מגזרת תרגום מטה:
חטר Rod. Comp. חוטרא, the Chaldæan translation of .מטה
גזע. כמו זרע:
גזע Seed.²
footnotes: ² A. V., The stem. Ibn Ezra does not give the derivation of the word; in the three passages of the Bible where it occurs, it can be translated either stem, or seed.
ונצר כמו סעיף, כנצר נתעב (ישעיהו י"ד י"ט):
נצר Branch. Comp. 14:19.
וטעם ויצא. כי קטן היה כאשר היה [צ"ל היתה] זאת הנבואה:
And there shall come forth, etc. Hezekiah was very young at the time of this prophecy.³
footnotes: ³ Comp. ix., note 9.
ונחה. על משקל ושבה אל בית אביה (ויקרא כ"ב י"ג), מהשניים הנראים:
ונחֽה And shall rest. Comp. ושבֽה (Lev. 23:13), And she shall return. It is a verb ⁴.(נוח) ע״ו
footnotes: ⁴ The rule is that the third person feminine past Kal of verbs ע״ו has the accent on the first syllable, but with Vav conversive on the second.—I.E. means perhaps to say that ונחה is derived from נוח, not from ינח.
והנה פרש כי רוח יי היא רוח חכמה ובינה, וכן כתוב על יהושע בתורה (דברים ל"ד י"ט):
The spirit of the Lord, that is, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, such as, e.g., was assigned to Joshua (Deut. 34:9).
וגבורה. כי גבור היה חזקיה, כי כן כתוב (דברי הימים ב' ל"ב ה'):
And might. Hezekiah was mighty, as stated (2 Kings 20:20)
והריחו. פעמים תטעה הרגשת האוזן שתשמע ואין קול, גם העין תטעה שירא' לה הנח שהוא נע, רק הרגשת הריח לא תטעה, והריחו, כאילו יריח הדבר ביראת השם שיש לו, לא ישפוט כאשר יראה לעיניו, ולא כאשר ישמע, כי יתכן להיות עדות העדים שקר:
והריחו And his enquiry.⁵ The ear is sometimes deceived in hearing sounds, which are only imaginary; the eye, too, sees things in motion, which in reality are at rest; the sense of smell alone is not deceived. He will properly investigate the question before him by his piety; he will not judge according to what he seems to see or to hear, because the testimony of the witnesses⁶ might be false.
footnotes: ⁵ A.V. And shall make him of quick understanding.—I. E. derives והריחו from הריח, to smell, and explains why this verb has been chosen to signify to enquire, or to investigate properly. ⁶ The witnesses, is either to be taken literally and referred to to hear alone, or figuratively signifying the eye, and the ear, and referred to both to see, and to hear.
ואלה התוכחות והמשפטים הם כמשפט המלוכה:
The rebuking and judging mentioned in this verse are privileges of royalty.
ושפט בצדק דלים. כמשפטי התורה שלא יהדר פני דל (שמות כ"ג ג'):
And he will judge the poor with justice. According to the rule, Neither shalt thou countenance the poor in his cause (Exod. 33:3).
והוכיח ביושר. לטובים:
ביושר ═ במישור With equity. לענוי ארץ The meek of the earth. The good.
והכה ארץ. בפיו כאילו הוא שבט לרשעים:
With the rod of his mouth. With his mouth, which is, as it were, a rod for the wicked.
והיה וגו'. והנה הצדק לא יסור ממנו כל ימיו בכל מעשיו:
And righteousness shall be, etc. And uprightness will never depart from him in all his doings.
וגר זאב וגו'. דרך משל מהשלום שיהיה בימיו:
The wolf shall dwell, etc. The peace that will be in his days is now figuratively described.
ומריא. פירשתיו (ישעיהו א' י"א) שהוא מין ממיני השור וחלבו אסור:
ומריא I have already explained (1:11); it is a species of cattle, the fat of which is forbidden.⁷
footnotes: ⁷ See 100:1, note 27.
ופרה. היא גדולה כי העגל קטן ויש אומרים כי הנקבה חזקה מהזכר:
פרה The large cattle; the younger of the breed is called עגל (ver. 6). Some assert that the female of cattle is stronger than the male.⁸
footnotes: ⁸ This remark of I. E. is perhaps to explain, why the feminine form פרה is used with the masculine רב for the whole species.
יאכל תבן. כאילו יסור מנהג תולדתו ולא יזיק לטרוף:
Shall eat straw. As if his nature had changed, and he would no more, in seeking prey, inflict suffering upon others.
ושעשע. לעולם תמצא בטעם הזה כפולה:
ושעשע And shall play. In this sense the word has always the reduplication.
חור. הפה או האף:
חור The aperture of the nose or mouth.
מאורת. העין שהיא בעלת האור:
מאורת The eye, which receives the light.⁹
footnotes: ⁹ חור and מאורת are usually explained as the holes from which the animals mentioned in this verse come forth. A. V., Hole, Den.
יתכן היות ה"אהדהתחת י"וד ידו אליה (ירמיה נ' י"ד), והטעם ישלח ידו, או אין לה אחות:
הדה He stretches forth; ה perhaps for י. Comp. יְרוּ stretch forth (Jer. 1. 14); or it is hapax legomenon.¹⁰
footnotes: ¹⁰ According to the first explanation הדה is not hap. leg., although no other instance of the word is found in the Bible, because several examples are found of ידה, which is considered to be same as הדה.
לא ירעו. על הפתן ועל הצפעוני, כאילו כל ארץ ישראל מלאה דעת יי, כי ידוע הוא כי יודע השם לא ישחית לעולם רק יבנה ויתקן:
They shall not hurt, etc. The asp and cockatrice will do no harm, as if all Palestine were full of the knowledge of the Lord; for it is an acknowledged fact, that he who knows the Lord will never destroy, but always build and improve.
כמים. תחסר מלת אשר, וכן הוא, כי הדעות תרבינה כמו אשר יכסו המים [צ"ל המים אשר יכסו] על ים, שלא יפסיקו רק תוספנה:
כמים אשר לים מכסים ═ כמים לים מכסים Knowledge will increase, like the water which covers the sea. The water is never stopped, so knowledge will continually make progress.
והיה וגו'. אם על המשיח, שכל העולם כלו תחת רשותו, ועל דעת ר' משה הכהן הנזכר על אות השמש, כי כן כתוב לדרוש המופת (דברי הימים ב' ל"ב ל"א):
To him shall nations seek. To him, that is, to Messiah, shall nations seek, that is, shall all nations be subjected. But according to the above-mentioned view of R. Moses Hakkohen,¹¹ this verse may predict the circumstances which would accompany the miracle of the sun; comp. the princes of Babylon, who sent unto him to enquire of the wonder (2 Chron. 32:31).
footnotes: ¹¹ That this chapter refers to King Hezekiah, not to Messiah.
והיתה מנוחתו כבוד. בכבוד וכן הנמצא בית יי (מלכים ב' י"ח ט"ז):
בכבוד ═ כבוד With honour; comp. בבית ═ בית in the house (2 Kings 18:15)
והיה. שנית, כנגד גאולת מצרים, והנה לאות כי על ימי המשיח ידבר, כי גאולת בית שני לא היתה גאולה שלימה, כי כל השבטים גם כל יהודה לא שבו אל ארצם,****והמפרש על חזקיהו שהתקבצו למלכותו כאשר ראו כי נמלטה ירושלם ומת סנחריב אחרי מות רובי [צ"ל רוב] מחנהו:
The second time, with regard to the deliverance from Egypt. This verse may be taken as a proof¹² that the prophet in the whole passage refers to the Messianic period; for the restoration during the second temple was not. complete,¹³ since not all the tribes, and not even all the men of Judah, returned to Palestine. He who refers the chapter to Hezekiah finds in this verse the description of the return of the people¹⁴ to Palestine, when they found that Jerusalem had escaped uninjured, and that Sennacherib had died after the loss of the greater part of his army.¹⁵ his men died, but I. E. in his commentaries frequently remarks that כל all, is not to be taken literally. Compare I. E. on Ex. 16:6.
footnotes: ¹² According to the view of the majority of commentators mentioned in the beginning of this chapter. The general redemption of Israel, as predicted in this verse, did not take place in the days of Hezekiah; for the ten tribes remained in exile. ¹³ The deliverance of Judah from the Assyrian invasion in the days of Hezekiah did not correspond to the promise given in this and the following verses. ¹⁴ In consequence of the Assyrian invasion, a great many of the Israelites seem to have left Palestine, in order to avoid the miseries and dangers of war and foreign occupation. ¹⁵ This is not quite in accordance with 37:36; there it is said that all
ונשא. כאילו השם ישא נס לכל הגוים שיראוהו ישראל וישובו אל ארצם:
And He shall set up an ensign. God will, as it were, lift up a banner among all nations, in order that the Israelites should see it and return to their land.
והנה ישראל עשרת השבטים, גם הזכיר יהודה:
Israel. The ten tribes,¹⁶ for Judah is mentioned separately.
footnotes: ¹⁶ I. E. fails to show how he can explain the return of the ten tribes, according to the opinion of R. Moses Hakkohen, who says that the whole chapter refers to Hezekiah.
וסרה. שלא יקנא אפרים בעבור שהמשיח הוא ממשפחת יהודה, ואם חזקיהו בעבור עמוד מלכותו:
The envy also of Ephraim, etc. Ephraim will not be jealous, that Messiah will be of the tribe of Judah; or, if Hezekiah be the person here indicated, that his kingdom will be strengthened.
וצוררי יהודה. שונאיהם. ואם על חזקיהו על ארם, והנה לא יצור את אפרים להשיב להם גמולם בימי פקח:
And the adversaries of Judah. The enemies of Israel generally;¹⁷ if the prophecy refers to Hezekiah, Aram¹⁸ is to be understood. Shall not vex Ephraim, by taking revenge for their hostilities in the days of Pekah.
footnotes: ¹⁷ של ישראל must be supplied in the text; the phrase שונאיהם של ישראל is a phrase often met with in the Talmud and the Midrash. It is perhaps omitted by the carelessness of the copyist. Without this interpolation the remark of I. E. remains without sense. ¹⁸ Aram is named as the ally of Israel against Judah.
ועפו. יש אומר כמו מגילה עפה (זכריה ה' א') פרושה, ורבי משה הכהן אמר כי אין רע לו, והטעם כמו ינוחו ויחסר מקום ארץ:
ועפו According to some, And they will spread;¹⁹¹⁹ comp. מגלה עׁפה A roll that was spread (Zach. 5:1). According to R. Moses Hakkohen it is hapax legomenon, and means they will rest. פלשתים Supply מקום or ארץ The place, or the land of the Philistines.
footnotes: ¹⁹ A. V. They shall fly, flying. ¹⁹ A. V. They shall fly, flying.
ימה. שהם מערב ארץ ישראל:
Toward the west. The Philistines dwelt in the west of Palestine.
בני קדם. הם ארמים:
Them of the east. The Syrians.
משלוח ידם. שישלחו ידם לבוזזם:
They shall lay their hand upon Edom and Moab, in order to spoil them.
ובני עמון משמעתם. יסורו אל משמעתם:
משמעתם. Supply יסורו אל or יסורו תחת Will come under their supremacy.
והחרים. יכרית, כמו וכל חרם (ויקרא כ"ז כ"ט), שיעברו בו ישראל ביבשה ולא יעכבם הים שישובו מהרה:
והחרים And shall utterly destroy. Comp. חרם doomed to destruction (Lev. 27:29). The Israelites shall then cross upon dry land, and the sea shall not hinder them by rapidly returning to its bed.
בעים. אין לו אח, והמ"ם שורש, וטעמו כמו בכח, והמפרשים אותו מגזרת אם תבעיון בעיו (ישעיהו כ"א י"ב) לא ידעו הדקדוק:
בעים Hapax legomenon. ם is part of the root. The meaning of the word is, with strength. Those that compare it with תבעיון בעיו (21:12) have no knowledge in grammar.²⁰
footnotes: ²⁰ The root of בעיו is בעה, while in בעים the ב is a preposition, and עים strength is the root.
הנהר. הוא היאר:
הנהר The Nile.²¹
footnotes: ²¹ הנהר The river is frequently used as a proper noun for פְרׇת Euphrates; so also in this verse, according to Rashi. But the tongue of the Egyptian sea being mentioned before, it is not impossible that the river refers to the Nile.
והדריך. פועל יוצא לב' פעולים:
והדריך And make go over. It is a verb with two accusatives.²²
footnotes: ²² Men and river.
והיתה. והנה פירש טעם החרם והמכה:
And there shall be an highway, etc. This verse explains the purpose of the utter destruction and smiting (ver. 15).
כאשר היתה וגו'. רמז לבקיעת ים סוף:
As it was to Israel, etc. This refers to the dividing of the Red Sea at the Exodus from Egypt.