Ep 90 - Torah, Guilt, and Prayer: The Power of Rabbinic Rulings (Bava Metzia 84b)

From Thinking Talmudist Podcast: Rabbi Aryeh Wolbe by R Aryeh Wolbe.

• Published: Fri, 31 Oct 2025 01:00:00 -0500
• Duration: 18:14
• Books: Bava Metzia
• Sections: 90a, 90b
• Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/media.transistor.fm/a4361bff/c55f5456.mp3
• Page: https://share.transistor.fm/s/a4361bff
• TorahApp: https://torahapp.org/share/p/3P_torch_r_aryeh_wolbe_thinking_talmudist/e/108d47b0-f644-41ed-8eed-060d369219b0

In this episode of the Thinking Talmudist Podcast, Rabbi Aryeh Wolbe continues the discussion of Tractate Bava Metzia 84b, focusing on Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon’s emotional and spiritual struggle after executing a guilty laundryman (referenced from a prior episode, likely tied to the “vinegar, son of wine” incident). The episode explores themes of guilt, divine justice, Torah study, and the efficacy of prayer, connecting them to personal anecdotes and broader Jewish responsibilities. Key points include:

• Rabbi Elazar’s Guilt and Suffering: Rabbi Elazar, a marshal who executed a disrespectful laundryman (justified by the man’s capital offense), feels lingering guilt despite following the law. Like a police officer experiencing PTSD after a justified shooting, Rabbi Elazar cannot rely on his reasoning to absolve himself and accepts physical suffering as atonement. He suffers a severe illness, losing blood and pus nightly, but recovers after his wife prepares 60 types of fig-based food (lifta). He converses with his afflictions, inviting them at night but dismissing them in the morning to avoid disrupting Torah study, showing his dedication despite pain (0:26–3:32).
• Wife’s Reaction and Wealth: His wife, frustrated by his self-imposed suffering and believing he squandered her father’s wealth, leaves for her father’s house. Sixty sailors then bring Rabbi Elazar 60 slaves with 60 money bags, preparing 60 types of lifta, restoring his wealth. He tells his daughter to inform her mother that “ours is greater than theirs,” citing Proverbs 31:14 (from Eishet Chayil) to affirm that Torah brings sustenance from afar. His wife’s absence allows him to return to the study hall (3:32–6:45).
• Rabbinic Rulings and Validation: In the study hall, Rabbi Elazar examines 60 blood samples from women checking for ritual purity (tahar) during their seven clean days post-menstruation. He declares all samples pure, enabling marital resumption after mikvah. Other rabbis question the statistical likelihood of all 60 being pure, suggesting an error. Rabbi Elazar prays that if his rulings are correct, the women will conceive boys (who cannot become niddah); if incorrect, at least one girl (who can become niddah) will be born. All 60 babies are boys, named after him, validating his rulings and demonstrating divine confirmation (7:07–14:21).
• Transmission of Halacha: Rabbi Wolbe explains the expertise required to identify impure blood, a skill transmitted from Moshe at Sinai through generations of rabbis, including himself, underscoring the mesorah (oral tradition). This parallels other halachic details (e.g., temple offerings) requiring precise training, like distinguishing colors of blood (8:39–11:27).
• Prayer’s Efficacy: Addressing his daughter’s question, Rabbi Wolbe shares a personal story of praying at the Western Wall for a son to fulfill Pidyon HaBen (redeeming the firstborn), which was granted, and accepting Hashem’s choice of a daughter for his second child. He clarifies that Hashem answers all prayers, but not always as requested, citing “Ein Tfilason Chozeres Reikam” (no prayer returns empty). Answers may be “no” or “wait,” tailored to what’s best, as seen in Rabbi Elazar’s answered prayer (15:04–17:08).
• Broader Lessons: The episode emphasizes human sensitivity in upholding justice (Rabbi Elazar’s guilt), the transformative power of Torah study despite physical suffering, and the communal responsibility to trust expert rabbinic rulings. Rabbi Wolbe connects this to the upcoming holidays (Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Sukkot, post-October 8, 2025), urging listeners to carry forward spiritual growth and good deeds.

_____________
The Thinking Talmudist Podcast shares select teachings of Talmud in a fresh, insightful and meaningful way. Many claim that they cannot learn Talmud because it is in ancient Aramaic or the concepts are too difficult. Well, no more excuses. In this podcast you will experience the refreshing and eye-opening teachings while gaining an amazing appreciation for the divine wisdom of the Torah and the depths of the Talmud.
_____________
This Podcast Series is Generously Underwritten by David & Susan Marbin

Recorded at TORCH Meyerland in the Levin Family Studios to a live audience on September 12, 2025, in Houston, Texas.
Released as Podcast on October 31, 2025
_____________
Listen, Subscribe & Share: 

• Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/thinking-talmudist-podcast-rabbi-aryeh-wolbe/id1648951154
• Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0cZ7q9bGYSBYSPQfJvwgzm
• Share your questions at aw@torchweb.org or visit torchweb.org for more Torah content. 
  _____________
  About the Host:
  Rabbi Aryeh Wolbe, Director of TORCH in Houston, brings decades of Torah scholarship to guide listeners in applying Jewish wisdom to daily life.  To directly send your questions, comments, and feedback, please email: awolbe@torchweb.org
  _____________
  Support Our Mission:
  Help us share Jewish wisdom globally by sponsoring an episode at torchweb.org. Your support makes a difference!
  _____________
  Listen More
  Other podcasts by Rabbi Aryeh Wolbe: 
  • NEW!! Prayer Podcast: https://prayerpodcast.transistor.fm/episodes
  • Jewish Inspiration Podcast: https://inspiration.transistor.fm/episodes
  • Parsha Review Podcast: https://parsha.transistor.fm/episodes
  • Living Jewishly Podcast: https://jewishly.transistor.fm/episodes
  • Thinking Talmudist Podcast: https://talmud.transistor.fm/episodes
  • Unboxing Judaism Podcast: https://unboxing.transistor.fm/episodes
  • Rabbi Aryeh Wolbe Podcast Collection: https://collection.transistor.fm/episodes
• For a full listing of podcasts available by TORCH at http://podcast.torchweb.org
  _____________
  Keywords:
  #Talmud, #Justice, #Law, #Morality, #Guilt, #Redemption, #TorahStudy, #Faith, #Patience, #Prayer